W3C Editors' Home Page

Introduction

One of the main accomplishments at W3C is to write specifications and create standards out of them. While the Working Groups at large are responsible for building consensus on the technical decisions, the editors have the heavy responsibility of transforming these decisions into actual specifications.

This page tries to gather resources that can help editors do their job: documentation, tools, tutorials, etc. If you know other resources that would benefit editors by being listed here, please inform the W3C Communication Team at w3t-comm@w3.org.

Where to start?

If you are a newly appointed editor in your Working Group, here is some advice that should be useful to get you started.

• Get an idea of the role of an editor at W3C
• Check the most popular editing tools: Bikeshed, respec
• Read the W3C Publication Rules (often referred as pubrules) and ask advice on the points that are unclear; if your document doesn’t comply with these rules, it cannot be published as a W3C technical report.
• How to Organize a Recommendation Track Transition explains the process to get a document published as a technical report.
• The Pubrules Checker is a tool that can help you assess whether or not your document complies with pubrules.
• Review WCAG
• All W3C editors are invited to join the publicly archived mailing list <spec-prod@w3.org> to share and discuss the techniques and tools used to produce W3C specifications.

Guidelines on W3C specifications editing

W3C has developed a set of resources giving advices and guidelines on editing W3C specifications in varous domains:

• The W3C Manual of Style is a collection of rules you’re invited to follow to make your document clearer and adapted to the common style at W3C.
• Begun in 1992 and only a little out of date, the Style Guide for online hypertext by Tim Berners-Lee is a good start on writing for the Web; see also Jakob Nielsen’s How Users Read on the Web
• The QA Framework: Specification Guidelines from the W3C Quality Assurance Activity are a work in progress that became a Candidate Recommendation in November 2003.
• The Team has guidelines for a style for group-internal drafts to avoid confusion with documents published on the TR page. Please also review the related Working Group Heartbeat Requirement of the W3C Process.

Bert Bos’s essay on W3C’s design principles and Tim Berners-Lee’s essentials of a specification may also be a useful reading.

During the internal development of a specification, make sure to distinguish official drafts from internal ones using the style for Group-internal Drafts.

Grammars

W3C editors have developed several types of HTML and XML based grammars to make it easier to develop and maintain their specifications.

Authoring tools

• Check the most popular editing tools: Bikeshed, respec
• Some tips and tricks for API architecture design: Web API Design Cookbook
• Some WhatWG conventions.

Tools

Here are tools that can prove to be useful when developing your specification.

• The Pubrules Checker provides a convenient interface to check the conformance of a document to pubrules (see pubrules issues and tracking)
• The TR references checker may help maintain your references list up to date. See also the IETF references checker.
• The W3C Glossary is a repository of all the terms defined in W3C specifications (and more); a good source to find which terms have already been defined and where
• The on-line Spell Checker helps spot misspellings and typos
• different tools are available to produce a diff between 2 HTML versions of a document; W3C offers an on-line HTMLDiff service
• The MarkUp Validator can help you assess whether your documents are valid HTML, MathML or SVG.
• The CSS Validator tells you if your use of CSS is correct.
• The Link Checker catches all the broken links that may have popped up in your document.
• HTML Tidy, originally by Dave Raggett and now maintained at SourceForge.net, is a lint that cleans up but does not validate HTML and XHTML. With indent off, Tidy can sometimes shave 10% or more off file size.

Most of these tools can be quickly accessed using the so called ,tools interface: appending ,keyword to a www.w3.org URI triggers a certain tool on this URI; for instance, appending ,validate to this page’s URI will send it to the HTML validator.

Central JavaScript repository

Specifications should, of course, be device-independent. But, with care, you can still include certain kinds of scripts. If the script you want is in W3C’s repository of common JavaScript libraries, you’re recommended to link to that repository, rather than make a copy of the script. (Note that, together with the common style sheets, these scripts are the only resources that may be outside the specification’s own directory.)

There is no documentation for now (except for MathJax).