Present: joshua cornejo, gabriel huecas, nicoletta fornara, victor rodriguez, juaquín salvachúa, yassir selami
Regrets:
Chair: victor
Scribe: victor
An informal conversation on different evaluation systems takes places. Reference is made to Cedar Policies. Joshua’s implementation, in C#, includes partOf, memberOf… It treats policies as assets, enabling complex rules that refer to other rules.
Owner: Victor
Status: Early Review
Open Issues: Github
Notes: No new examples have been created. Renato and Joshua discussed on refinements (https://github.com/w3c/poe/issues/312). The refinement of an action is clear to Joshua but some gaps have been identified (what about list of actions?). This issue may trigger new examples to clarify the point. When the issue is closed, please update the BP document.
Owner: Joaquin
Status: Under Development
Open Issues: Github
Notes: No news given the summer break that just finished. The profile will be submitted to GaiaX, connectors are being produced.
Owner: Ben
Status: Close to Review
Open Issues: Github Issues
Notes: Nothing to be reported.
Owner: Nicoletta
Status: In Progress
Open Issues: Github
Notes: The formal semanticss document has been updated with the lifecycle of the duty. Fulfilled is no longer a final state, the evaluation is continuous and the state can fall back. A new example has been created (22.1) that clarifies constraint on a duty (“active only on sunday”). Others: please check example 22.1. The semantic of prohibition has been updated as well, aligning with the ODRL information model.
Yassir would like to see more complex examples and hints to see how to make the evaluation –a compliance engine to test the implementation would be greatly appreciated. A long discussion follows with no clear conclusions.
Owner: Beatriz
Status: New
Open Issues: Github Issues
Notes: Beatriz was not pressent in the call.
General Open Issues: Github Issues
W3C ODRL Model/Vocab Recommendation Errata: Github Issues
W3C TPAC meeting is taking place soon. An ODRL meeting was expected for September by 23rd (read the issue), however it is not officially listed and the deadline for registering passed in June. Interest from Harsh Pandit and Beatriz to meet in relation to DPV CG was shown. Victor to inquiry on this.
No
Date: Monday 07 OCTOBER 2024