W3C POE WG: ODRL Candidate Recommendation - Implementation Report

This report is part of the ODRL CR Test Regime: http://w3c.github.io/poe/test/test-regime

Latest update of this report page: 2017-11-13

EC ID: Exit Criteria ID, see CR Exit Criteria
TC ID: Test Case ID, set Validation and Evaluation
Test by Val: tested by a Validation case
Test by Eval: tested by an Evalution case
Formal/{Implementation id}: result from matching the result generated by the implementation against the ODRL test case
Comment/{Implementation id}: comment by the implementer on the test (case)

Implementation Reports

Implementer UPM: Facultad de Informatica @ Universidata Politechnica de Madrid, Spain

Homepage: http://fi.upm.es/
Test updated on: 2017-11-09

Implementer IPTC & NIT: IPTC (International Press Telecommunications Council) & NewsIT

Homepages: https://iptc.org, https://github.com/nitmws/odrl-wprofile-evaltest1/tree/master/evaluator
Test updated on: 2017-11-13

Implementer TR: Thomson Reuters

Homepages: https://www.thomsonreuters.comTest updated on: 2017-11-11

EC ID	TC ID	Exit Criterium (in bold) or Test Case	Test By Val	Test by Eval	Formal/Implem UPM	Formal/Implem IPTC & NIT	Formal/Implem TR
CR-IM-01		A Set/Offer/Agreement Policy type with required properties
CR-IM-01	E12-1	A Permission without constraints or duties		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-01	N1	Internalization of parties and assets declared out of the policy	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	N2	Type declaration of policy elements	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	N6	Inferences derived from odrl:includedIn	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	N7	Inferences derived from odrl:implies	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	V1	A valid document must contain at least one Policy	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	V2	Every policy must have at least one rule	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	V3	Every policy must be identified by a URI	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	V4	Every rule in an offer must have exactly one assigner	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	V5	Every rule in an agreement must have exactly one assigner	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	V6	Every rule in an agreement must have exactly one assignee	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	V7	Every rule must have exactly one target	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-01	V22	Every prohibition must be disjoint with permissions and obligations	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-02		A Policy that utilises an ODRL Profile
CR-IM-02	V12	In absence of profile, only ODRL Core actions can be used	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-02	V13	In absence of profile, only ODRL Core left operands can be used	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-02	V14	In absence of profile, only ODRL Core operators can be used	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-02	V15	In absence of profile, only ODRL logical constraints operands can be used	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-03		A Policy with an Asset Collection, including parts
CR-IM-03	N8	Inferences derived from odrl:partOf for Asset Collection	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-04		A Policy with a Party Collection, including parts
CR-IM-04	N9	Inferences derived from odrl:partOf for Party Collection	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-05		A Policy with a Rule including a constraint property
CR-IM-05	E13-1	A Permisson with a constraint		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-05	E13-2	A Permisson with a constraint		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-05	E18-1	A Permission with a constraint		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-05	E18-2	A Permission with a constraint		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-05	V16	Every constraint must have exactly one right operand	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-05	V17	Every constraint must have exactly one left operand	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-05	V18	Every constraint must have exactly one operator	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-05	V19	The values of every logical constraint must be constraints	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-05	V20	The values of the property rightOperandReference must be URIs	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-05	V21	Every value of the property odrl:datatype must be of type rdfs:Datatype	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-06		A Policy with a Permission including a duty property
CR-IM-06	E22-1	A Permission with a duty with a constraint and refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-06	E22-2	A Permission with a duty with a constraint and refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-06	E22-3	A Permission with a duty with a constraint and refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-06	E22-4	A Permission with a duty with a constraint and refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-07		A Policy with a Permission including a duty and a consequence property
CR-IM-07	E23-1	A Permission with a duty with a consequence		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-07	E23-2	A Permission with a duty with a consequence		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-07	E23-3	A Permission with a duty with a consequence		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-07	E23-4	A Permission with a duty with a consequence		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-07	E23-5	A Permission with a duty with a consequence		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-08		A Policy with a Prohibition
CR-IM-08	E19-1	A Policy with a permission and a prohibition		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-08	E19-2	A Policy with a permission and a prohibition		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-09		A Policy with a Prohibition including a remedy property
CR-IM-09	E24-1	A Prohibition with a remedy		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-09	E24-2	A Prohibition with a remedy		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-09	E24-3	A Prohibition with a remedy		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-09	V8	No remedy can refer to a duty that includes a consequence duty	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-10		A Policy with an Obligation
CR-IM-10	E20-1	An Obligation with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-10	E20-2	An Obligation with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-10	E21-1	An Obligation with a consequence with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-10	E21-2	An Obligation with a consequence with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-10	E21-3	An Obligation with a consequence with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-10	E21-4	An Obligation with a consequence with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-10	E21-5	An Obligation with a consequence with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-11		A Policy with a refinement property on an Action, Asset and Party Collection
CR-IM-11	E14-1	A Permission with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-11	E14-2	A Permission with a refined action		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-11	E16-1	A Permission with a refined AssetCollection as target		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-11	E16-2	A Permission with a refined AssetCollection as target		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-11	E17-1	A Permission with a refined PartyCollection as assignee		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-11	E17-2	A Permission with a refined PartyCollection as assignee		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-11	V9	Every AssetCollection with a refinement must have a odrl:source	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-11	V10	Every PartyCollection with a refinement must have a odrl:source	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-12		A Policy with a Logical Constraint
CR-IM-12	E15-1	A Permission with an action refined by a Logical Constraint		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-12	E15-2	A Permission with an action refined by a Logical Constraint		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-12	E15-3	A Permission with an action refined by a Logical Constraint		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-12	E15-4	A Permission with an action refined by a Logical Constraint		x		PASSED	PASSED
CR-IM-12	V19	The values of every logical constraint must be constraints	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-13		A Compact Policy that requires translation into an Atomic Policy
CR-IM-13	N4	Interiorizing policy-level properties	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-13	N5	Expansion from compound to irreducible rules	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-14		A Policy containing metadata
CR-IM-14	N10	Policy Replacement	x				PASSED
CR-IM-15		A Policy that includes Policy inheritance
CR-IM-15	N3	Application of inheritance rules	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-15	V24	No policy can inherit directly or indirectly from itself	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-16		A Policy that includes a Conflict Strategy
CR-IM-16	V11	In absence of profile, only ODRL Core conflict strategies can be used	x		PASSED		PASSED
CR-IM-16	V23	Every policy most have at most one conflict strategy	x		PASSED		PASSED