W3C

VCWG Digital Product Passport

9 November 2026

Attendees

Present
Carolynn Bernier, dr._susanne_guth-orlowski, ivan_herman, ivo_ladenius, m.-a._wolf, phil_archer, rigo_wenning
Regrets
-
Chair
-
Scribe
transcriber

Meeting minutes

Meeting Introduction

Ivo_Ladenius: Good afternoon. How are you?

Ivan_Herman: Hello. I'm okay.

Ivan_Herman: Here we go. Everybody covered from Dublin. Oh, you were not in Dublin.

Rigo_Wenning: No, I wasn't a Dublin.

Rigo_Wenning: You know, Ivan, I'm not No,…

Ivan_Herman: Yeah. No, because a number of people turned out to be sick.

Rigo_Wenning: I I Yeah, but you didn't.

Ivan_Herman: No, I did not. My wife did, but I did not.

Ivo_Ladenius: You want your wife was also going, right? Your wife was also in Dublin,…

Ivan_Herman: Mhm. Yeah,…

Ivo_Ladenius: right? Yeah.

Ivan_Herman: but she she she got a bit sick.

Ivo_Ladenius: Uh yeah,…

Ivo_Ladenius: that's unfortunate. But still, uh we got to see the city.

Ivan_Herman: She She did.

Ivan_Herman: I did not. I mean, yeah, I know that's unfair. On Sunday, I had a day where I could walk around.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Thank you.

Ivan_Herman: Hello Carly.

Carolynn Bernier: Hi Suzanne.

TPAC Meeting Summary

Carolynn Bernier: Um I was not at the TAC meeting. Uh were anyone there at the TAC? Uh maybe provide us with a summary of…

Ivo_Ladenius: Yeah, actually.

Carolynn Bernier: what was said. Indeed.

Ivo_Ladenius: Yeah, at our session I was uh scribing. Um so later I was thinking well that wasn't the smartest idea uh describe your own u topic.

Rigo_Wenning: Um, so I think most most of the reports are rather positive.

Rigo_Wenning: I heard at least from a data perspective. Uh, as I'm the optimist and Ivan is the pessimist. Um uh you you you you find the middle ground that probably the truth is the middle ground between the two of us.

Ivan_Herman: I am just realist.

Carolynn Bernier: Um I'm Does it make sense that I share the slides that uh Ingo prepared?

Carolynn Bernier: Ingo cannot be here today. Um

Ivan_Herman: No, I don't think I mean all in all I if we concentrate on on Inko's slides for the minute I think they were very positively accepted.

Ivan_Herman: So there were no really controversy uh there were no discussion. It's it's was sort of universally accepted that this should be part of the final document. The only thing that did come up and which is still pending is that this example as well as the three others because now there are three others not only two uh at least in preparation are valuable uh by themselves. Uh VC or…

Ivan_Herman: control vocabularies. There go the question.

Carolynn Bernier: So uh Mar we're going to talk about…

Carolynn Bernier: what was said during the TAC meeting two weeks ago the work that was and what is the status what was discussed and what are the the uh so uh now uh Ivan was talking about the um the examples the ecosystem example examples to the recognized entity recommendation.

M.-A._Wolf: Okay. Well,…

M.-A._Wolf: so today we have we have more the entity and…

Carolynn Bernier: So uh well actually I don't know…

Ivan_Herman: Yeah. I have no idea.

M.-A._Wolf: the verifiable credentials topic because I got confused. What is Wednesday? What is Monday? This is why I'm asking otherwise I I leave you rather I clicked on the link that was an old series was continued as another series continued as another series and…

Carolynn Bernier: if the Monday meetings are they still happening on the wallet vocabularies. Please.

Rigo_Wenning: Um last uh yeah uh I think last time Ingo and…

M.-A._Wolf: somewhere I found this link

Ivan_Herman: Uh I am also extremely confused to be honest.

Rigo_Wenning: I we were uh only the two of us. Um it was really productive. Um, so I don't think it it it's totally given up. Uh, but I think it needs a a kind of a rebase uh in and…

Wallet Work Discussion

Carolynn Bernier: It's for the wallets.

Rigo_Wenning: collecting more support than just ferity uh for the wallets. But we have a new movement on wallets uh which is Casten suggested to the working group um to to unblock the um the situation uh that uh for the moment um Etsy uh EN9472 mandates the high assurance uh profile interoperability profile hype from

Ivan_Herman: Okay.

Rigo_Wenning: Open ID which itself because written by the other the other side mandates uh um SDC only. And so the the custom suggested that uh uh W3C may want to make its own high assurance profile because it it needs that for uh world interoperability and…

Rigo_Wenning: not only Europe and Etsy is happy probably very happy to reference that uh but that's under discussion and this is very important for the wallet stuff and includes of course the recognized entity and all of that.

Carolynn Bernier: Okay. So,…

Carolynn Bernier: there's no decision yet made on the…

Rigo_Wenning: No, no,…

Carolynn Bernier: if Okay.

Rigo_Wenning: no. Just just uh uh an input to the working group uh for discussion.

Carolynn Bernier: Yeah. So, basically the wallet discussion is uh floundering a bit at the moment because as you say, Spity needs there needs to be more interest for the for the on the specific wallet. Um I'm a bit surprised that there's no one in in digital bazaar that because they're walk like work they're working on business credentials for many different applications. I'm a bit surprised that there's no one from digital bazaar interested in the the work the vocabularies for wallets but anyways. So uh there there are two topics. There's interest from China to join us and uh for Chinese organizations to be able to join us at this hour is difficult.

Meeting Time Change

Carolynn Bernier: So uh there is a request that we can possibly change the the meeting time to uh morning with that for the moment there's no one from us joining us in our reg in our meetings very regularly so should we just move to mornings the

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Uh who who is interested in joining from China? Good. No, I have no problem with that.

Ivan_Herman: Well, I I would have a problem,…

Ivan_Herman: but then I am not. No, usually my my whole setup is such that in the mornings I I I usually do not work.

Carolynn Bernier: Which uh when when would because Oh,…

Ivan_Herman: I mean that's my my 50% timing is such that I start around lunchtime and and in the afternoon uh in the morning I usually have other programs.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Mhm. Carolynn Bernier:

Carolynn Bernier: I think I so I think early afternoon could do could be okay for the Chinese cuz they usually work late anyways. So I think if we move to 1 would be okay.

Ivan_Herman: That's that's different. Yeah. Now that would work, but but not not before.

Carolynn Bernier: Uh would like one on Wednesdays,…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: works for me as

Ivan_Herman: Check it.

Carolynn Bernier: either Mondays or or or Fridays or or Tuesday Thursdays.

Ivan_Herman: Friday is snow. Thursday.

Carolynn Bernier: Thursdays there Okay.

Ivan_Herman: doesn't work for me. Wednesday or Monday work.

Rigo_Wenning: Thursdays don't work for me.

Rigo_Wenning: I have a standing conflict there. Uh Wednesday would work and…

Carolynn Bernier: Uh, Monday would be fine for me.

Rigo_Wenning: um Monday would also work.

Ivo_Ladenius: Yeah, for me it's more than fine.

Carolynn Bernier: Monday at 1.

Ivan_Herman: That works for me.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah. Mhm.

Carolynn Bernier: I I I think I would prefer Monday at 1 because when I have to travel, the Wednesday usually jumps. Monday 1.

Ivan_Herman: Now, Caroline,…

Carolynn Bernier: Okay. Yes.

Ivan_Herman: we have two meetings which are set up for this task force. One on Wednesday, I believe, and one for Monday. At least that there was a time when we had two.

Rigo_Wenning: Yes. And I'm totally confused.

Ivan_Herman: I have no idea what's happening now.

Rigo_Wenning: Yeah, exactly. I'm totally confused because I have now the Wednesday meeting was for wallets at 1,600.

Ivan_Herman: Yes. And Wednesday was for DPP. Um,

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Mhm.

Rigo_Wenning: So, we should remove that one, right? Yep.

Carolynn Bernier: No, the Monday meeting was for wallets.

Carolynn Bernier: Exactly. So now the DPP one is will move to Monday 1:00. And then if the the the question is do is there still a need for a wallet meeting?

Rigo_Wenning: Um I frankly I was skeptical in the first place…

Carolynn Bernier: Mhm. Okay.

Rigo_Wenning: because it's it's drying out. We we are already not 50 people in here.

Rigo_Wenning: um and it's drying out and splitting overly splitting and I don't see a sperity alone you know only me taking care doesn't doesn't help and uh um if we have a common meeting I think the problems they they they uh they actually present will also interest the others because uh uh in in

Rigo_Wenning: Everything is a puzzle.

Carolynn Bernier: Yeah, I understand.

Carolynn Bernier: Regal, we had we had a bit of a leadership problem because it was very difficult to say who. It's easy when it's, you know, Carolyn is leading the meeting.

Rigo_Wenning: Yeah. But…

Carolynn Bernier: Carolyn defines the the agenda and…

Rigo_Wenning: but I I think we have a solution for that is that we go up to Brent and…

Carolynn Bernier: Carolyn, you know,

Rigo_Wenning: Phil and Casten has no time anyway. And uh that way we kind of Ivan and I talking to or Ivan uh talking to Phil and Brent uh we will have um uh the the fact that you are leading this task force and…

Rigo_Wenning: I think uh Casten will be happy in two because they don't have time anyway and then we are fine.

Carolynn Bernier: Right. Okay.

Rigo_Wenning: And but I think we should do this now because otherwise we will lose the entire group…

Rigo_Wenning: because of unclarity on phone and this andarity here and unclarity there. Ivan, what do you think?

Carolynn Bernier: Okay. Right.

Ivan_Herman: Okay. Uh can I come back on that…

Ecosystem Examples Discussion

Ivan_Herman: because I would like to finish what I started to say about TPAC which Rio hijacked um just because it's it's in a way relevant. So the presentation of ingo with the uh the use case was very positive and as I said it's number four as a example in the list of examples in the recognize entity spec and you know there are details that have to be finalized etc.

Ivan_Herman: Let's not go there for details but it's it's it's it should be done. It should be there. The only question that did come up at some point uh is that and we are talking about the four example not only on this one. They are all very elaborate and important examples which go way beyond the kind of examples that we address in the various specification and which shows the possible complexities that VCs are are are good for. So there is one question pending is whether we would sort of span off into a separate note uh with the four examples because it's exemplary for the whole verifiable entities sorry verifiable credential infrastructure and…

Ivan_Herman: family etc not only for the recognized entities.

Ivan_Herman: So that's spending we it was mentioned on the during the meeting and that's something that we have to come back to. I think it would be much better if the if this example will not be sort of hidden in one specific specification but it would be a standalone not a standalone document but a standalone document with the four examples.

Carolynn Bernier: So is that done?

Ivan_Herman: So GS1 uh the UN there is now a metronomy example coming up and this one it should be done within one or…

Carolynn Bernier: So uh so this when will this decision be made?

Ivan_Herman: two week I presume it depends on the chairs not me but uh and that's something that we may well you actually may want to raise on the working group meeting on

Ivan_Herman: Wednesday. Yes,…

Carolynn Bernier: uh so I I won't be able I won't be available…

Carolynn Bernier: because I'll be in a conference in Italy but uh uh so the the the idea is that these ecosystem examples are not hidden in a recommendation they are like it's a way to put highlight them a little bit more to put them in a specific technical document Okay,…

Ivan_Herman: exactly. Exactly.

Carolynn Bernier: that I'm perfectly fine with this. Mhm.

Ivan_Herman: So that's a working that would be a working loop note. So there is no you know heavy administration around it but I think it would be very useful.

Ivan_Herman: So that's one thing that come up and the other thing and this is where we come back to the discussion we started to have is apart from this it was very difficult to explain the group what is happening I mean the rest of the group what is happening they were asking whether you know are now this task force producing working group notes or are they producing a recommendation if it is a recommendation it has to go certain

Ivan_Herman: steps etc. And in fact both Ingo and I were very uncertain about that. So that comes back to what Rio said that creating this how do you say that super secure VC profile is is a specific very concrete step which has its very goal and that's clear we can we can do that and we should do that. Uh but Ingo has to be around to finish the example at the the stage where it is he has become editor of it. He should be around. So I would not like to see going away and leaving that example just hanging in the air. That would be the worst.

Carolynn Bernier: Okay.

Rigo_Wenning: um Ivan Ivan I I just had them on the phone uh uh last week and…

Ivan_Herman: So we should be very clear about that.

Ivan_Herman: Um, okay.

Rigo_Wenning: uh they are very committed so I I don't see I don't see them running away uh and…

Ivan_Herman: Okay. Okay. Rigo Wenning:

Rigo_Wenning: and for uh for recommendation versus note. Uh it really uh I really stand by the words I've I've sent during the uh high assurance profile discussion is this really is dependent on whether it is needed in this kind of co-regulation environment. If it's needed in the co-regulation environment,…

Rigo_Wenning: we must produce a recommendation because that only can be normatively referenced. a node can you cannot uh uh and…

Ivan_Herman: I I understand.

Ivan_Herman: I understand that,…

High Assurance Profile Discussion

Rigo_Wenning: and that's the the only criteria I would I would

Ivan_Herman: Ro. Yeah, I I understand that. But uh we we had a separate discussion, Ro and I, on email uh last week. Uh my problem is that I have no idea what a higher assurance profile is. I have to understand that and we have to understand what is really involved when we talk about a high insurance profer for VC. Whether the end result is a recommendation or a note from this point of view is a is a separate issue. Uh I don't know what it means and I don't know whether it means rewamping

Ivan_Herman: certain parts of the VC or just picking the features that are acceptable or not acceptable. That's something that we have to know before we engage into any kind of recommendation work. No. Okay.

Rigo_Wenning: Yeah, absolutely.

Rigo_Wenning: And uh uh I would the first step Ivan would be to invite Simona to present that…

Carolynn Bernier: I think so.

Rigo_Wenning: because Simona knows precisely what that means.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: So are you talking about um um quality uh quality insurance high with regards to AI does speak?

Rigo_Wenning: Yeah. And quality qualified signatures. Susanna, it's it's it's about qualified signatures.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah. Okay.

Rigo_Wenning: And uh there is this kind of semantic uncertainty because in a VC you can have a pointer to an external vocabulary. Now if you have this external vocabulary you can redefine terms which may means you cannot uh um is the this open world assumption. Uh and now if you have um if you can um access this remote repository…

Rigo_Wenning: where your vocabulary sits and you can redefine that vocabulary, you can change the meaning of the credential and that's that's part of of the issue and they are they are more like that.

Carolynn Bernier: Wait, you done

Ivan_Herman: in. Can I can I can I quickly react on that?

Ivan_Herman: In in in the case of a in the case of the JSONLD setup of the whole thing,…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: So I Yeah,…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: I talked I talked

Ivan_Herman: what you say is not possible because all the to be very technical all the context file for VCDM and the others are heavily protected and you cannot override things. So there this is something that VC has been prepared for.

Rigo_Wenning: Okay.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: I've talked to to Simon a Simon On…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: who was the from W3C the security guy I met him in I don't know where were we somewhere last year this year I don't know together with the UN ECE people the UNP people including Steve Kapad um and he uh assured me that you can download um kind of the JSON LD file um as well so that it's verifiable. You can download it and then it doesn't change anymore. You can also download in advance and then the security problem that the rebuild people have doesn't exist because they do the same with their rule books which I think is now how they call them.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Um so I I don't really think that we have an issue there and uh but I understand we need the qualified um electronic seals issued by qualified trust service providers supported by uh certificates for uh qualified electronic signature which which is what I'm working with every day because uh Our customer have to register against the DPP registry where this is needed. Um, so I don't know did I was I breaking up I don't know your your pictures. Yeah.

Rigo_Wenning: Yeah. No, no, not that. But that's is this is precisely what I'm saying is is is we need a kind of a profile to cater to that and there is one profile perhaps one profile uh for the EU. There will be perhaps another one for China, another one for the US and…

Rigo_Wenning: we can make perhaps sure that they interoperate. Uh but but Ian The hype has has several has several uh u constraints on the normal profile.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: But are we talking about defining defining the quality assurance level that the credential and…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: the signature have or what are we talking about? What what are we trying to to do? Yeah, then that that's the right thing to do.

Rigo_Wenning: Several on protocols on se several things. Um we have this discussion because Ivan has uh the annoying but very beneficial uh habit of wanting to know exactly…

Carolynn Bernier: Mhm.

Rigo_Wenning: what we are doing.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: I also exactly want to know what we're doing because then I only I can contribute in a proper way. So, uh, Ian

Ivan_Herman: uh in view of all this discussion…

Ivan_Herman: what is exactly the Chinese want us to do because if we bring in the Chinese and this has nothing to do with what we are talking about and it's yet another different work…

Rigo_Wenning: This was just an example,…

Ivan_Herman: then I am Not sure we want that.

Rigo_Wenning: Ivan. It was just an example. For the moment, it just says, look, for the moment, our only use case is the EU because they are leading the game. But Caroline can tell you that the DPP mania goes around the world and…

Rigo_Wenning: the others are following up which means that there is I cannot exclude that at some point in time the Chinese want to have their own high security profile.

Carolynn Bernier: Exactly. The DPP mania will transfer to the wallet mania soon.

Carolynn Bernier: And I just for Ivanne who is not aware of this, Ivan, I think you're the only one in this call who is not aware that on October 30th, the commission published artifacts for the battery DPP. On that website, you will find a very interesting document that uh is called uh uh semantic data artifacts and semantic data guide. And if you go there, you will see that the commission uh is using uh Scots to describe the content of uh uh passport. And so they they have started to develop vocabularies that will be hosted by them.

Carolynn Bernier: and will that will be mandatory for European DPSPs. So this is a very how shall I put it uh important moment and currently and this touches our work here on DPP vocabularies. It touches our work because the commission is publishing mandatory vocabularies and China may publish mandatory vocabularies and US may publish mandatory vocabularies and so this is to be expected. Okay. And the purpose of this group is to create interoperability.

Carolynn Bernier: So um first of all it's a very good thing that the commission it was very uncertain until last week that the commission would actually do this. So already we are rejoicing that the commission is taking this approach to uh ensuring the semantic interoperability of the European DPP. So this is a very good thing. Like Rigo and I, we danced a little joy, a dance of joy because we spent the last four years trying to get the commission to take on this approach. Okay. So this is good. So now what we're doing is we're trying to analyze what the commission has published in their artifacts uh zip thing, how the shackle shapes work.

Carolynn Bernier: for for the moment we haven't been able to get them to work. They have a recursively def defined uh import um mechanism for the context. So they seem to have bugged uh or like for the moment we we don't understand how their their their work actually works. Um, and we need uh we're looking at it inside surplus 2, but anyone who who knows how you can validate JSONLDD with shackle shapes should take a look at this because uh may maybe we we don't understand how how they're doing it and and so we're following their guidelines to try to get their JSON to validate.

Carolynn Bernier: Um, yes, Susan. So as the question we need to answer is for a DPP to be compliant in the EU.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: So um UNP. what I also want to put on the table is that we already have more than what the European Commission has in UNP. We have a logical model for digital product passports which hopefully um allows interoperability. Now the question is what additionally do we do in this group to facilitate interoperability? Is it the same? shackle files. I think we go to a logical model uh first which where everything can be mapped and therefore it will be interoperable. Dr. Susanne Guth-Orlowski:

Ivan_Herman: Okay.

Carolynn Bernier: do must it reference those specific that specific name space is uh name space I

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah, of course. Yeah, you have to you have to use that definition.

Rigo_Wenning: Why not? Yeah. And one of the reasons Susanna is um is that uh I was running after the commission for a long time now uh saying look if you put a shackle shape into an implementation into a delegated act right if your shackle validates you you have a presumption of conformity which

Rigo_Wenning: is a nice thing because then you don't have to ask to suit whether they can confirm that you know you see what I mean and…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah. Yeah.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah. No, I understand. And technically that's that's the right thing to do. I also think that the business of to suit doesn't make sense,…

Rigo_Wenning: and nobody prevents and…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: but Yeah.

Rigo_Wenning: that's where Kolin comes back nobody prevents uh then the commission to use

Rigo_Wenning: in JSON LD a mixture of UNTP terms and some extensions they want and this is because and why do we do this here because at the end it's JSON LD at the end it's verifiable credentials and and at the end we need this relation uh to W3C and you cannot you cannot create or or maintain that kind of coherence from the UNP P side, it's much easier to maintain it from the W3C side.

Rigo_Wenning: And that's why Steve Capel uh uh was also kind of pushing pushing us to uh to take that up.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Um, and…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: related to this, I just spoke to the entity data people that are implementing the DPP registry. They confirmed that they will be supporting W3C verified credentials. They don't do it yet. So you don't find it in the documents that Caroline is mentioning and that I shared the link with in in the chat as well…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: but they will be so definitely we will there will be W3C verifiable credential um I don't know specification no I don't didn't see that it's me talking.

Carolynn Bernier: Wait, wait,…

Carolynn Bernier: wait, wait, wait. Where? Where did you see that? Ah. Uh,…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: to the entity data people. Yeah. Yeah.

Carolynn Bernier: okay. That's that's good. But we're not even there yet. Let's get you're you're a step later.

Carolynn Bernier: Let's get the Jason LG.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: I'm but but but it tells us that we're doing the right thing and we have to continue doing it because they might look at what we did you know to to point to um a specification I don't know data model whatever we want to do yeah or whatever the real output is from this working group What is the roll off? Yeah.

Carolynn Bernier: Ian, your hand is up.

Ivan_Herman: So Susan had touched upon this…

Ivan_Herman: but my question is as a complete and absolute outsider uh what is the role of VCs on all that of VC

Carolynn Bernier: role a VC a VC is an optional wrapping layer on top of the DPP.

Rigo_Wenning: Ah. Um,…

Carolynn Bernier: You can you c you you can issue a DPP in the EU without a VC,…

Ivan_Herman: because I haven't seen anything.

Carolynn Bernier: but it has to be JSON or optionally JSONLDD and optionally wrapped in a VC.

Rigo_Wenning: then I let let me let me unpack my uh lawyer head. Um so uh justice has to be seen to be done Ivan and there's nothing easier than faking any JSON file you can find out there right and now imagine that you have track and trace where decisions whether you you are allowed to import or not into the European market a a series of products that when you talk

Rigo_Wenning: When Kolene talks to the industry,…

Rigo_Wenning: their first concern is, hey, they will create fake DPPs and uh you know duplicate DPPs to um to import stuff into the European market and…

Ivan_Herman: Okay. All right.

Rigo_Wenning: we have already uh there is a study from I think it's France um a study in France that says over 80% of the goods imported from China are nonconformant.

Ivan_Herman: So, you want to explain that to our Chinese people when they come to come to the group. Yeah. No, I'm just uh I just saying uh I understand that.

Carolynn Bernier: We will be more politically correct.

Carolynn Bernier: Oh, Phil, uh, we said we're

Ivan_Herman: I understand that and I I realize that,…

Ivan_Herman: but it's still unclear.

Rigo_Wenning: We have an exception.

Rigo_Wenning: They have an exception for the Brits. But just…

Rigo_Wenning: because Phil is

Ivan_Herman: Uh, I think I still uh don't tease Phil with Brexit…

Ivan_Herman: because once he gets started, we can't stop him. Um, So again just asking stupid question of course you need a VC I understand that but what is what this group has to do because that's what I don't understand VCs are there vocabularies are defined somewhere we are not a vocabulary definition group so what is the extra that this working group can give us that's what I still

Ivan_Herman: Miss Why not here?

Rigo_Wenning: Ah, that that's that's perhaps a discussion that you have to have with me and…

Carolynn Bernier: Why not here? Yeah.

Rigo_Wenning: Ptoan because it's mainly about W3C process.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Why? Why?

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Why I'm excluded? I want to be part of that. So, let can I can I just It's okay.

Ivan_Herman: No, it's not. No, no, no, no, no. I'm sorry, Ro. This is This is not true. And I'm not talking about any kind of processing. I want to understand what is the value added part of VC working group in this respect. VCs are there. VCs are yes we add new things. There are a number of things that we have to finish. It's all fine. What is it that we add as a working group to this process? This is my question.

Ivan_Herman: Sorry, Susanna. Yes.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: It's a valid question. I just wanted to uh share my my landscape and how I see the world with you guys. Best I best work in bits and bites and code. Um so my understanding is that everything that's in the credential subject if this is a verifiable credentials that shows a battery passport. Yeah. We have the outer structure which is what is mandatory for verify the credential and then we have the credential subject and everything that's in the credential subject is our DPP. For that we will be having a schema that is defined elsewhere.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: uh this is probably going to the European Commission in future but we will be having loads of them. I'm now working with the Chinese automotive industry to define a battery a Chinese battery ID passport in UNP which will also get a vocabulary defined in a JSLD file. And I think what we could do is to allow that this credential defined here for from the European Commission and the one from China is somehow interoperable. For this we need a joint data model where we can map this both to to make it interoperable. That could be one thing that we can do. uh but that that's also done by UNP and I don't want anything that we do here to diverge from uh UNP. So we can also look

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: at UNP 1.0 which is coming out soon and…

Ivan_Herman: U um and…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: say look at that data model there we endorse it that's fully how we want to uh make everything interoperable job done so my five cents

Ivan_Herman: I fully understand that and again I just want to be the the enemy here uh who ask uh stupid questions. It's fine that that's perfectly clear what the goal is. But this is not something which logically speaking should be take place in the verifiable credentials working group. This is yes this is a work to be done.

Ivan_Herman: Yes, eventually this is a group a work that should be done at W3C, but it it uses VCs unless it comes back to the VC working group are saying…

Ivan_Herman: what you have here as a specification is unfinished because we need this and this and this feature. Uh the VC is just a tool for you and that's fine. That's the way it should be. So that's why I'm asking

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Okay. Yeah,…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: you you're fully right. Can I ask add one more thing? So now we have the proof. Yeah, we were looking at verifiable uh at qual assurance levels of signatures. I don't know if if we have something in here. Yeah. So what we will be needing is for the qualified electronic attestations of attributes which are giving us digital identities with the public key in there from the uh you know business register of Germany for example Bulisa Falak they give they sign something with a signature that has an insurance level high or…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: an insurance level substantial that means…

Ivan_Herman: What does that mean?

Ivan_Herman: I'm sorry. Dr. Susanne Guth-Orlowski:

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: how secure your identity is bound uh to your DIT or to your identifier. So insurance level high the highest insurance level that you can get means that your electronic uh public private key pair has been issued um by a qualified trust service provider. There's only a handful of those. they have to undergo the highest security processes technically and process-wise in the EU and you have to be on that registered list. So that's the highest thing you can get. I don't see a field that says this this signature comes from you know it's it has insurance level high.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: So if you ask me that's an attribute that's missing and that we want under the qualified electronic additional attri attributes if it's issues an identity but it's not necessary for the digital product passport today because there substantial so insurance level substantial is enough…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: which is you know you can produce your own public private key and your self-signing certificate I I don't know it's it's in here or not.

Ivan_Herman: So, So,…

Ivan_Herman: so now now we are now we are talking as I say because if my understanding is correct you can identify in through this example you can identify a feature that in view view is missing from the specification of signatures as defined by the VC we have a very clear structure to hold the signature the public key and what's not and you need one or

Ivan_Herman: to additional attributes there that are missing and that should be yeah that's that's what you are talking about um so that's that's the kind of thing I am looking for strictly and selfishly from the VC point of view and this is something that you would come back to the working group saying you guys in this and this example for this and these purposes and for this and these reasons we think that there is a missing feature in your structure for proof then becomes a discussion for the verified arches.

Ivan_Herman: This is the kind of thing I am looking for and this is what is relevant for the group. I'm sorry Phil I took too much

Phil_Archer: No. Um,…

Phil_Archer: what you say is correct. Um, Ivan, I don't disagree with you. However, um the value to the group as a whole of the people around this virtual table right now is enormous because through the efforts of the very people on this call right now you've got European Commission talking about W3C verifiable credentials. They haven't done that before. they can't they you actually got real examples of how this stuff can actually work and why this particular approach works rather than some other approaches we might mention all these things matter and bring value to it. Now um speaking as um where I work um the thing that W3C is really really bad at I mean astonishingly bad at is promoting its own standards. It kind of assumes everyone else will do it.

Phil_Archer: Oh, we're coming from W3C, therefore it must be perfect. That's not the way the world works. And what's happening here is people saying, "Yep, we can use that with few little tweaks and so on." And it's a massive boost to the group. And I don't care if it doesn't add in a single technical requirement. The value to the group and the value to the work that we're doing overall, the value, dare I say it, to California driving licenses of this group is huge.

Ivan_Herman: Now put on your chair hat uh for a change and…

Rigo_Wenning: This is unfair.

Ivan_Herman: then let's discuss about let's see let's discuss about the working groups efforts and…

Rigo_Wenning: This is unfair.

Ivan_Herman: manpower. Why?

Phil_Archer: We have a group that is doing the work. Carolyn

Rigo_Wenning: This is unfair. This is unfair. Ivan, it it's the it's the it's the W3C killer argument…

Ivan_Herman: Sorry, Ro.

Carolynn Bernier: Uh I I think Ian's questions are perfectly legitimate.

Rigo_Wenning: which uh which doesn't work here because the the the value that Phil mentioned and that's why I didn't want to talk about it because

Ivan_Herman: Rio, let let Caroline talk. She just started to say something. Carolynn Bernier:

Carolynn Bernier: Why are we here? what is the value etc. Thank you Phil makes my heart you know uh really I I feel great that that that you think that this brings value and I also think that the commission endorsing W3C verifiable credentials would be a huge bonus to W3C. Um but more coming back more specifically to Ian's questions this group the goal of this group is to contribute to the working groups recommendations like we have already started to do with a recognized entity to…

Ivan_Herman: Yeah.

Carolynn Bernier: because the wallet the wallet DPP use case is a multivvc ecosystem use case. It's a comp very complex use case with high assurance things and low assurance things and international things and so it the the complexity of the use case is enormous and if we can make and so we we simultaneously want to contribute to the recommendations being designed in the group but we also simultaneously need to benefit from the expertise of the group in order to design to make sure that

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: That's better.

Carolynn Bernier: the use case works properly. So, so I don't care. It is likely that this group will never write a recommendation. It is likely and it doesn't matter. It doesn't have to as long as we contribute to tech technical documents of other work groups. Uh and and that's it.

Carolynn Bernier: So I'm fine if if we don't ever write a recommendation. I think the work is still very important. You're done.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Um yeah,…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: I like um I like just you know if you we identify something that we need anyway such as insurance level is missing why don't we just work on that one define define it and we have a little piece of the puzzle done and I don't think once we agreed on that this is missing we can just work on it and…

Carolynn Bernier: Get up.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: then move on like because we've been also starting this group I don't know…

Rigo_Wenning: There's a

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: how many months ago and we don't have output so yeah yeah I saw yeah I saw I saw all all this this diagram…

Carolynn Bernier: No, no,…

Carolynn Bernier: no, no, no, no, no, no. That is that is a because you missed the last two months of meetings. But we uh

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: but I also don't know where it leads to uh exact yeah so what What what's the output document of that?

Ivan_Herman: No, there is there His There is an output document.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: of that.

Ivan_Herman: Susan Ingoing has has edited a a use case document that he presented in in uh Dublin…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah. Yeah, I saw it.

Ivan_Herman: which was

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: He he did send it around. He was asking for feedback. I looked at it. Okay. Yeah. But uh um so my suggestion is we have we have found one thing that we need to add…

Ivan_Herman: Yeah.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: which is insurance level at least two signatures because we need it. Let's some people just start it uh write something down and…

Carolynn Bernier: Exactly. I just forward to you the proposal made by Karsten to the working group leadership to do exactly…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: move on. Okay. Okay.

Carolynn Bernier: what you just said. So I just forward it to you now. Bill

Phil_Archer: I just going to to highlight that exact email,…

Phil_Archer: Caroline. Thank you. Um, it's in my inbox. I recognize I thought, "Oh, yes, I've got to do something about that. It came in on Thursday. I haven't dealt with it, but I need to." Um and uh yes, it's on the we will need to discuss whether we can do it under the current charter or whether we need to rechart it because for everything that Susanna just said, it's clearly very important and we need to get our head around what it actually means and whether we could do it without whether we come under this group um existing. But um uh yes, I can see uh it's clearly important and and I my mind goes to does the confidence method cover it? No, it doesn't. Here we go.

Rigo_Wenning: Yeah. The assumption of saying uh this group what does this group uh um uh contribute to verifiable credential has the the second implicit uh assertion that um if it doesn't it it it has no reason to live. And uh this reminds me of the multistakeholder platform that did um uh recommend um uh that that did uh specification recognitions for the sole effect for the sole reason because the procurement guys were ignoring this anyway.

Rigo_Wenning: for the sole reason that for the group to exist there there was the obligation of having a function and so um unhook invented that function for recognizing specifications. Um so here I think Susanna is very has a very very good argument. We need to have this uh kind of function to define those two three attributes. Now we have a reason to live but this the the the the reason for this group goes way beyond like Phil and…

Rigo_Wenning: Caroline uh just mentioned.

Carolynn Bernier: And I'm happy Suzanne,…

Carolynn Bernier: if you and Karsten want to work on the high assurance profile and and that those attributes and that that's that's fantastic. Mhm.

Rigo_Wenning: Caroline, the the the high assurance profile. goes f way beyond. I had the discussion with Ken and I said clearly to him W3C um is is currently very short on on on manpower and resources and I said um that if we take up that work it can't be severity alone and K said they have an entire ecosystem of industry players um uh for who who uh uh who think that's really important for them now and I said casten if you can manage to engage them then we are fine and and I think that's the challenge now that's that's the old challenge that I…

Carolynn Bernier: Mhm.

Rigo_Wenning: if you that that that's argument number three from Iran if nobody wants it why would we do

Phil_Archer: What was what was the argument?

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah. But but the argument is also always and that's what we do for the last five years. People don't know yet that they need it. Yeah. I mean,…

Phil_Archer: Yeah. Yeah.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: how how do you convince the industry? They they're not as nerdy as we are trying to make it all work. I can I can understand that comes along. They educate everyone around them. Yeah. including myself that that's that's something that we need uh and how this can all work together. But uh they don't know they want it and therefore they don't spend resources for people to join the call is true.

Ivan_Herman: The chicken and…

Rigo_Wenning: Suzan, that's that's that's a standard argument number four saying this is a chicken egg problem.

Ivan_Herman: egg program.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: So does that mean we cannot do it? Does that mean we cannot do kind of the first version and…

Rigo_Wenning: No, it it just Yeah,…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: if it's if if now everyone found out that it's they need it for implementation we can improve it.

Rigo_Wenning: it it it it just the difference is we need to be aware that the doc that and we need to be open about that the industry is not coming here to kind of classic standardization meaning uh we already have five versions of something and…

Carolynn Bernier: Hi.

Rigo_Wenning: now we want to come together to find one common version. No, here it is classic innovation management.

Rigo_Wenning: classic innovation management and standardiz I've done so many presentations on why standardization today on the internet is classic innovation management is we have to reach out and say look that's the idea uh do you see yourself jumping on the bandwagon and can you contribute which is different than hey there's a working group if you're interested to play uh come here uh if you have a solution that is similar to this one which isn't the case of something That's doesn't exist

Carolynn Bernier: Right. Okay. So, so uh just to be clear, I don't know anything about high assurance profiles and what needs to be done to get that to work.

Ivan_Herman: Good. I am not alone.

Carolynn Bernier: So, so

Rigo_Wenning: Um, I've done I've done uh um I've done uh the the qualified electronic signature the first directive of 99.

Ivan_Herman: Thank you, Caroline. It's a warm feeling that I am not alone with that.

Rigo_Wenning: I've I've done uh I was part of the Etsy working group at the time.

Rigo_Wenning: I'm a very old man. Not as old as Ivan, but nearly. Um, so and…

Phil_Archer: than me as well. Never mind.

Carolynn Bernier: So are you saying Rigo that you Suzanne and…

Rigo_Wenning: and I I think with the help of Simony,…

Carolynn Bernier: Karsten can write the uh the high assurance profile W3C Simona Suzanne Car and…

Phil_Archer: I just heard him say that. Yeah.

Rigo_Wenning: we can

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah. No, we we we we find it's probably good…

Carolynn Bernier: Rigo. Wonderful.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: if we have this this small group and then we have people uh outside that can validate it. Yeah. for example like Stefan Schwam if we can ask him because he's the Aidas guru in Europe and…

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: I'm talking with him regularly so I'm I'm sure we get a very high quality definition. Yeah.

Phil_Archer: So then any questions whether we can do it under the current charter or…

Phil_Archer: not? Um yeah we can work. Yeah.

Ivan_Herman: that can be worked out here somehow.

Rigo_Wenning: Yeah, but…

Ivan_Herman: Let's let's worry that later.

Rigo_Wenning: but but that's Phil that's a that's a new uh internal nice challenge because everybody's jumping up and down and says the process is so bureaucratic. Now we come with a use case where we say hey you know we need this kind of little amendment should we have the full monty you know blah blah or…

Rigo_Wenning: or can we just adapt and that's a real challenge to the process pro professionals. That's

Phil_Archer: Well, thankfully the person in charge of the process is also my co-chair of the group,…

Phil_Archer: so we're kind of in good uh in good shape on that one. So, Brent, here's your challenge. Get this through.

Carolynn Bernier: Uh okay. So that's that's good. Um how in let's come back to process. Okay. So, do we need to have a specific meeting for that sub group for you guys or Suzanne Rigo or or should we use this this lot to talk about that? I actually would like to learn about how you would go about building such a high assurance profile based on ver I'd be interested to learn…

Ivan_Herman: Me too on both ends.

Carolynn Bernier: what this actually means personally, but I'm a geek.

Rigo_Wenning: No,

Phil_Archer: I'd like to I I think I think you're um among friends,…

Carolynn Bernier: you you you're a we're we're all geeks here.

Phil_Archer: Caroline, here with the on the thing. It's okay.

Carolynn Bernier: Good. All right. So we're we're all all interested to learn. Um so maybe but I can't lead that discuss discussion and either we talk about the recognized entity example from ingo and we continue working on that and improving that…

Carolynn Bernier: because that for the moment I think I saw a post from Manu asking ingo to make a pull request of whatever of his example. I'm not sure what is the status of Inko's uh work.

Ivan_Herman: Window has put in a pull request to the to the recognizable entities repo,…

Ivan_Herman: but it needs still a lot of work, but it's it's in the process. And to answer your question Caroline, we have already created two meetings for this task force. So we have two topics. We put them into the two meetings and we are done.

Carolynn Bernier: Right. So maybe but it depends if Suzanne and because we have two slots. We have the Monday at one…

Ivan_Herman: One. This one,…

Carolynn Bernier: which is our slot for the the Chinese friendly slot for DPP. And then there's another slot that we can use but we don't have to use which is Mondays on at uh Monday's 6 4:30 4:30 uh No,…

Ivan_Herman: 1600 our time.

Rigo_Wenning: No, no,…

Rigo_Wenning: no, no. That one was uh uh I think suppressed by by having this one.

Rigo_Wenning: I think it was moved to 1600.

Ivan_Herman: Yeah, in in my calendar I have two entries…

Ivan_Herman: which is this one at 1600 uh for for Europe central Europe time and we have uh

Ivan_Herman: actually Wait,…

Carolynn Bernier: no, no, no. I only I I moved only this this if you look at the calendar I just switched this is the Wednesday meeting that I moved to Monday because on Wednesdays I'm in a conference. Okay. So we're now in the Wednesday call. Okay. Even if we're Monday, we're we're currently in the Wednesday call. So if you look at the calendar,…

Ivan_Herman: wait, wait.

Carolynn Bernier: the DBP meetings are supposed…

Carolynn Bernier: if you go if you go to the the 18th of November one, the 18th of November is a Wednesday.

Rigo_Wenning: Can I make a suggestion because I'm I'm getting lost with those meetings.

Carolynn Bernier: Right. Right.

Phil_Archer: I am too.

Rigo_Wenning: Um so far about the high assurance profile and…

Ivan_Herman: And and when when do you say when you say you moved it, you moved it on the W3C calendar or not? But it doesn't work.

Carolynn Bernier: Yes. I moved in on the W3C calendar. I logged in and I Yes,…

Carolynn Bernier: it did.

Ivan_Herman: Yeah. Oh.

Carolynn Bernier: We're here. Look, if…

Phil_Archer: What's position?

Rigo_Wenning: the qualified electronic signature for manipulating the Carolynn Bernier:

Carolynn Bernier: if the the the the calendar you have to go to the W3C website to know…

Ivan_Herman: Oh, wait a minute. Wait a minute.

Carolynn Bernier: what the real calendar is because meetings get moved around all the time because I travel a lot. Okay, so that's the place where the truth is it's on the W3C website calendar page and I took the Wednesday meeting and…

Carolynn Bernier: I moved it to today. So I I brought forward by two days Wednesday's meeting. Okay. I did that just for one instance of the Wednesday meeting.

Ivan_Herman: No, but why?

Ivan_Herman: Oh, well,…

Carolynn Bernier: So, so,…

Ivan_Herman: I don't see them.

Carolynn Bernier: so look,…

Ivo_Ladenius: Every meeting from the business wallet is canled at at the calendar from the URL.

Carolynn Bernier: let me Ingo Ivo. Yes. Yes. I don't know why. I don't know why they're cancelled. Who canled them? So this was Wednesday's meeting that I moved to Monday. For some reason, these are cancelled. I don't know why. Then this this is the the next one is on next Wednesday on the 18th. If you look BDP,…

Ivan_Herman: Correct.

Carolynn Bernier: the next one is on the 25th, Wednesday. So it's these Wednesday meetings that I need to move to Monday at 1.

Rigo_Wenning: Yes, but there is no other Monday meeting anymore…

Rigo_Wenning: because it's all I I would merge them.

Carolynn Bernier: There is.

Carolynn Bernier: They've all been cancelled.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Yeah, let's them.

Carolynn Bernier: I don't know who canled them. Maybe Ingo did right.

Ivo_Ladenius: But another question,…

Ivo_Ladenius: do we do we want to merge them because the business wallets are only right now?

Rigo_Wenning: Frankly, I was against splitting them and I I want to merge Carolynn Bernier:

Carolynn Bernier: Uh okay. that the what was annoying w with was that we we said that we would alternate every week and I never knew who was leading what meeting and as long as I'm the leader then it's clear I'm leading the thing and if I I'm some it's hard to get a reach of Karsten co-leading something with Karsten is almost impossible he's never available so it was impossible to co-lead okay it was impossible right if if somebody needs to change a meeting, it needs to be clear who who changes the meeting. So, I'm it's okay for me to lead both. It's okay. It's clearer even if I know nothing about wallets.

Carolynn Bernier: Phil. Yeah.

Phil_Archer: I'm not seeing I mean I'm seeing ingo working on the um um conform to European use case.

Phil_Archer: I'm not hearing them do much talking about wallets as such. So yes, I think there is actually one series of meetings going on and it's this one. So and if there's something comes up then okay. Um so yeah I think one one one W3C meeting group sounds right. um uh modulo the meeting that now Susanna and Rio need to have talking about the I Yeah,…

Carolynn Bernier: No, no, they'll do it here because we all need to get educated. We all we all need to get educated and…

Phil_Archer: true. Yes.

Carolynn Bernier: learn how this high assurance thing works and what it means to to VCs.

Phil_Archer: Yeah. And I will just put my chair on for a minute.

Carolynn Bernier: So, so I suggest we keep this meeting and some meetings will talk about vocabularies and recognized entities and…

Ivan_Herman: So I know.

Carolynn Bernier: other meetings will talk about high assurance profiles depending on who's there, what's advanced. We'll see Why are you asking me?

Phil_Archer: Um there's other work that needs to be done and something else Carolyn that you'll be very pleased to know about. We are trying hard to organize our next face toface meeting in April. Where's the city in the world you would most likely to have a face toface meeting?

Ivo_Ladenius: It's confirmed.

Phil_Archer: Um if it isn't in at your place in in France, which is one option, where's the other place in the world you really really really would wish we would go and meet? because it's Montreal.

Carolynn Bernier: Oh, it's Montreal.

Phil_Archer: No, it's not confirmed,…

Carolynn Bernier: It's Well,…

Phil_Archer: but it's it's a it's a definite possibility.

Carolynn Bernier: it could be in Paris. Uh so so the issue the issue I have is um is uh CA still needs to sign the the um so I've got a lot of progress on this on CA joining W3C…

Phil_Archer: Uh Great will be easier for Revan certainly in that he could be there. Understood.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: Sorry.

Carolynn Bernier: but I'm still working on it. Uh so I almost get getting administered assigned. Okay. So just I'm still working on it but I'm making progress. So it's

Carolynn Bernier: Yes, but until until we are members, I can hardly like host the W3C a and…

Rigo_Wenning: No, we can always we can always host in Sophia.

Phil_Archer: Oh, that's I'd always forgotten that one. That's that's that's that's worth thinking of actually. That is worth thinking because that's easy to get to as well. Yeah. And and cheaper than parents. Okay. Thank you. I hadn't thought of that. Um we're out of time. Um so yes,…

Carolynn Bernier: Okay. Ah.

Phil_Archer: that hype thing is look we'll talk about that in a minute because Ivan and I have a call with Brent in half an hour. Um see if we can get that through. But yes, um if it's in the current charter, so April is when we're targeting another face toface meeting and we we do need basically everything in candidate anything that's that is on the rec track needs to be in candidate rack by April which means that high high assurance integrity stuff.

Rigo_Wenning: It's Phil. It's a profile. I I need to consult with Simona…

Rigo_Wenning: how complex that is because Simona understands this open ID for VC hype profile that that Christina Yasuda wrote Heaven.

Phil_Archer: Okay. If it be a note,…

Ivan_Herman: But but…

Phil_Archer: you know it's easy.

Ivan_Herman: but but but wait wait wait wait wait wait before you scare everybody Phil. I believe if we decide to go rack track with that one we cannot and we should not expect that to be in CR in April. Phil Archer:

Phil_Archer: I know. But I'm just trying it on to see if I can get there. I know. I know.

Rigo_Wenning: Yeah, I I was already starting to sweat.

Phil_Archer: CR for a document you haven't started yet in April is unreasonable. I know.

Carolynn Bernier: Okay. So right now yes.

Dr._Susanne_Guth-Orlowski: So, um

Phil_Archer: But I'm trying to crack the whip because our charter runs out in April 28, March 28. So anyway,

Ivan_Herman: Yeah. Uh before we go, Caroline, we have to have a final decision on which meeting we keep, which meeting we throw up and when. And I I I would propose to take this meeting we have now, turn it into a meeting for one o'clock on Monday,…

Ivo_Ladenius: But every Monday What's

Ivan_Herman: remove the one in Wednesday and be with it.

Carolynn Bernier: Yes, I was going to do that every Monday.

Ivan_Herman: Okay. Every Monday.

Ivan_Herman: Every Monday.

Carolynn Bernier: that one.

Ivan_Herman: And then we we sort of try to to keep an equal balance between the two work at the moment.

Carolynn Bernier: Right. Yes.

Ivan_Herman: You know, I think that the use case document will be done within a month or a half before the end of the year. So long term it will be the high insurance profile anyway.

Carolynn Bernier: Yeah, I suggest we do both. uh depending on who's there…

Ivan_Herman: Yeah. No, no, no. Of course. But yeah.

Carolynn Bernier: since we're all traveling where sometimes we're not there. So depending on who's present and what work has moved forward, I I must admit I haven't been able to look at all at what Ingo has said and Ingo's work. We need to review it, you know, line by line because remember we were saying that there was um there was a bit discussion on how uh the recognized by uh or recognition scope conversation and I don't think we finalized that conversation yet. So we need to have that conversation next week. I suggest we have

Phil_Archer: Uh yes on on that one a lot of work on the recon identity spec has happened and I haven't reviewed it yet but I think that that document is heading to candidate wreck next month so it does need to be prioritized Caroline so if there anything missing or wrong in the recon identity spec…

Ivan_Herman: What you have decided?

Phil_Archer: then it does need to be brought to the attention PDQ s***.

Carolynn Bernier: E except ah yes right…

Carolynn Bernier: but the example doesn't need to be finalized if if the example is going to be taken out of the recommendation and put in into a a kind of it's not yet decided Okay.

Phil_Archer: There are arguments for and against, but even even if it's in the wreck document, it isn't a normative bit. So, it can go in candidate wreck. Doesn't have to be ready for candidate wreck. The normative stuff does. So, if you need something changing, the normative stuff, that's the urgency,…

Carolynn Bernier: Okay. Right. Phil Archer:

Phil_Archer: not the informative. Y I'm going to Hburgg this coming weekend to talk to the metrology people.

Carolynn Bernier: Okay. So, next Monday we need to look at this work being done and and the recognition scope topic that was a big event a big issue uh before TAC. All right.

Carolynn Bernier: Cool. Cool,… Phil Archer:

Phil_Archer: Brett Highland's going to be there among others. So talking great.

Carolynn Bernier: cool, cool, cool. Very good. All right. Uh, Ivan, I know how to change the calendars now. So, I will do it. I will do it.

Ivan_Herman: Go for it.

Ivan_Herman: Go for it. The worst is if both of us try to do it at the same time. Yeah.

Carolynn Bernier: I will do it. Mondays at 1 and there I will inform the Chinese that they are welcome to join us.

Phil_Archer: That's really good. Thank you. Thanks all. See you soon. Cia. Bye-bye.

Ivo_Ladenius: Bye-bye. Meeting ended after 01:06:58 👋 This editable transcript was computer generated and might contain errors. People can also change the text after it was created.

This transcription was generated by a large language model (LLM) and might contain errors. When in doubt, check the audio recording. This page was formatted by scribe.perl version 248 (Mon Oct 27 20:04:16 2025 UTC).