Meeting minutes
Early Morning Calls
Joe Andrieu: Howdy, Scott.
Scott Jones: Hi, how are you?
Joe Andrieu: Good. Little tired. It's a little early for me.
Scott Jones: Yeah, I am East Coast.
Joe Andrieu: The West Coast as well.
Scott Jones: I uh I I would not be able to hang with 7 a.m.
Scott Jones: calls if I had to actually have cognitive like capabilities.
Joe Andrieu: Yeah, I used to be a night owl and…
Joe Andrieu: then I moved in with my partner who has kids and that changed everything. It's so much easier to go to bed early. Um, wake up early.
Scott Jones: How early are you getting up?
Joe Andrieu: Um, not that early. in the scheme of things. But as a programmer, you know, my whole life, like this is early.
Scott Jones: Yeah. Yeah,…
Joe Andrieu: Um, I would never have scheduled like I refuse to schedule 9:00 meetings in my previous company.
Scott Jones: my uh my whole my entry into the tech world was when I lived in Los Angeles and I got used to Oh,…
Joe Andrieu: Yeah. Yep.
Scott Jones: developers will roll in 10 10:30. Okay, cool. I can handle that.
Joe Andrieu: You might you might be staying till seven or eight or nine, but you know,…
Beer In The Workplace
Scott Jones: Yeah. Then the really interesting cultural thing I saw was the intersection of beer and…
Joe Andrieu: coming a little later. Yeah, that was me. Um, but the kids really did change things.
Joe Andrieu: So yeah.
Scott Jones: technology. I worked at a company where they had a keggerator. So some of these engineers roll in like 10 10:30 could just have pints of beer the whole day. Like wow.
Joe Andrieu: Yeah. Were you at Procore by any chance?
Scott Jones: No, it's called digital turbine. Mobile app monetization.
Joe Andrieu: Hello, Digital Turbine.
Joe Andrieu: That sounds familiar to me. Um, cool. Yeah, there's a company called Procore up here in uh, well, is it Pro? It's not Procore. It's um, it's the phone company I'm trying to think of. They had a phone like internet product. Anyway, they would host the Santa Barbara JavaScript meetup and…
Joe Andrieu: they had a lounge, you know, with a bar and a keg. That was just one of their perks. like in the basement of their building. Like why not?
Scott Jones: Yeah, I uh I appreciate it.
Scott Jones: Got them in the flow, but a lot of these people were not healthy.
Joe Andrieu: Yeah. Well, it's, you know, I had a a mistake related to to beer and what you what I think you just hit on.
Joe Andrieu: I um I helped produce um a play and at at the play it was with a bunch of burner friends, right? So it was that culture. Um we actually built our own stage on a on an empty dirt lot that a friend of mine owned um while he was trying to get a permitted like it had remediation had to do. Anyway, we it was a big huge crazy to-do and…
Joe Andrieu: as a social gesture, I would bring one six-pack of beer to rehearsal and sort of invite other people to bring a six-pack of beer and it turned out to be a horrible idea. Um, we had people show up absolutely drunk to the performance to to tech night like it sent the wrong message about…
Scott Jones: Yeah. Yeah.
Joe Andrieu: what we do together. And I thought I was just being social, you know.
Scott Jones: And what were you performing again?
Scott Jones: I missed that part of the story. What were you rehearsing? Oh, wow.
Vampiric Play
Joe Andrieu: Uh it was it was an original play by one of the co-ers about um it was a vampiric reinvention of the tale of um Uritici um or…
Joe Andrieu: Uritysy depending on how you want to pronounce it. So she was killed by an ASP on her wedding day.
Scott Jones: Wow. Wow. Wow.
Joe Andrieu: She is um Morpheus Orpheus's wife.
Joe Andrieu: and uh he went to the underground to bring her back and he succeeded and well he seated in the underground and then on the way back he was told um she will follow you but you will not hear her footsteps do not look back and of course he looked back um and you know it was Sodom and Gomorraesque in that he looked back and he sees her not yet corporal form just fade
Joe Andrieu: before his eyes. That's the end of the the real story. So, my co-producer had turned it into a vampire story that you she did in fact come back, but she was a vampire and then chaos ensues.
Joe Andrieu: You actually I think you could find it online. Unfortunately, it has me on stage in a rather embarrassing context, but you know Yeah.
Scott Jones: Very cool.
Scott Jones: Yeah, that doing that drunk sounds difficult. Yep.
Joe Andrieu: Well, I wasn't. The problem was, you know, the c the social cue, you know, as a as a leader, you have to frame the context. So, I'm not sure we're going to get anyone else. Scott, um, I had touched base yesterday briefly with Dan. Let me see if I have any messages from him.
Joe Andrieu: Um, were were you able to join at all on the TAC meetings?
Scott Jones: No, I was okay.
Joe Andrieu: No. Um, I could I could show you what we did there. Actually, I'd love to get your feedback on it. Um, so let me pull up that and you know, we don't need to spend the whole hour, but uh you'll see why I want your feedback. Okay, I've got two different views going into this diagrammy thingy. So, I'm going to share the whole screen so I can switch between them. Okay.
Biometric Template Validation Flow
Joe Andrieu: So um I started with this diagram which I've created I created quite a bit ago and I've shared with a group and it was designed to ignoring the flows because it was complicated with the flows just identify all the components and the first time we had done this it was an attempt to generalize across all of our confidence methods. Um but as I like forked that and um made one just for biometric template validation. Um uh no it's issuance that we should be looking at. Um I said hey let me let me make a copy and start adding some flows. Right.
Joe Andrieu: So, I'm just walking through you through the process because this is I abandoned this so don't look too closely. Doesn't really matter. Um, but I started renaming things and that helped a lot. When these were the more generic names, it was really hard to track what their actual role was. So, describing in pros what was happening here was a real um challenge. Um, the other thing I realized was I wasn't confident in sort of the highle flow. So that's what I did next and that's what I shared at TAC and what I'd like to get your feedback on. So the idea is that for each of our um different biometrics,…
Scott Jones: Mhm.
Joe Andrieu: we probably want um a flow like this. So this is the entire flow just in a simpler context. It's just entity to entity, right? So you have a holder, they're trying to get a credential that needs a biometric template from an issuer.
Joe Andrieu: This could be DMV if they were using the biometric template in a in the in the fashion we're describing. They require the template. Um the holder goes to a template creator. They says, "Okay, we'll make you a template." Our biometric operator is going to create a sample, right? This might be a photograph or fingerprints or DNA like it's sort of agnostic at this. But there is this operator who has to physically interact with the human being, right? So that's the distinction here. Whereas this is likely uh conceptually a service bureau. um whoever is running the service bureau, this is the person in the service bureau. So you get a data sample back um from the the operator who gets it into the software or system that the template creators operating. Um that is where the actual crypto happens like or the biometric magic to create the template. Um and this this really Oh, that's interesting. I wonder if I can make it a stereotype.
Joe Andrieu: Uh, well, that's interesting.
Joe Andrieu: I want I want to change it now. I want to change this into a person. That would be more clear. So, we've already created value, Scott, because I think making that a person would make this much clearer. Um, anyway, they get the biometric template back, the holder does. Um, and then they give it to the issuer who then embeds it in the credential. Is that how you imagine this flow working? So there is either a service bureau humans or it's the holder.
Scott Jones: Uh, the notion of humans being involved threw me off like the icon you're changing right now.
Scott Jones: Holder makes sense to me.
Joe Andrieu: Um but in some cases people don't trust the holder. Like you can't get UAL3 um today if it's just the holder, right? You need another person in the room. Um this is also how um we do the fair witness ceremony in the digital fiduciary initiative. Um which is there's there's a fiduciary who's a human who's in the room with you and…
Scott Jones: Got it. Yep.
Joe Andrieu: that's part of the quality assurance. Um they might be wrong but at least there was a human. wasn't it cannot be fully automated in its attack. Um but that is worth calling out when we describe this that this could be a human that that that human could be the holder is interesting and important I guess to communicate. So let me let me actually add that. Hold on.
Joe Andrieu: I've got a um write up of this. So that's an older version of the photo, but that's E2.
Scott Jones: Thank you.
Joe Andrieu: Uh, I don't yet have a dictionary. Okay. So, I'll just make a note at the bottom of this diagram.
Joe Andrieu: Okay, that's good feedback. I'll flow that in. It really should go in the dictionary where we describe that. Um, so the the next diagram is sort of the inverse of that.
Scott Jones: Mhm.
Presenting Biometric Credentials
Joe Andrieu: Um, so this is when you're going to uh present a credential with a particular biometric in it. So they're going to request some service, you know, I want to um I want to be a teacher at your school. They say, "Okay, well, we need a teacher's credential that has a biometric check in it because we don't want strangers coming into our classroom."
Joe Andrieu: um the holder who already has the verifiable credential goes and…
Scott Jones: Yep. Mhm.
Joe Andrieu: gets a timely biometric check with some provider and I think I'm guessing to your model this could be the phone again right so so if there were an operator in the loop that would be the holder again um or this is just software um so doing the I don't I don't know if we need let me just make a note should we should Feet. holder here. That was the wrong group. Uh, I'm actually curious what we're doing in the other diagram.
Joe Andrieu: No, none of those are the diagrams I want. Oh, great. My screen froze. Yeah, great. It seems like the something in the app just froze. Why is that thing open like that? Stop it. Okay. Um well, uh in short, I was just noticing we do have the operator and the biometric check flow in the diagram.
Joe Andrieu: So, um, we could make it symmetric if that seems to make sense. Um, let me try and find that other diagram. Oh, is that what happened? All right. Well, let's see if we can go back to this. Okay. I don't know why that isn't closing. There we go. Okay. Uh, so they request a check from a provider. The provider does a sample. um they evaluate the sample. Um and then uh we really should go ahead and have a generate credential…
Scott Jones: Biometric evaluation credential. H
Joe Andrieu: because we do have that as an explicit thing, right? As it's we call it a biometric evaluation credential.
Joe Andrieu: This is the second credential, right? There's this the credential that has the biometric in it and then this is what the service provider gives back so that the holder can deliver it to the verifier to say hey I've been to an acceptable biometric check system whether that's on my phone…
Scott Jones: Gotcha. All right.
Joe Andrieu: which I think is the realized pattern or if you made me go into a service bureau I also could have done that and gotten a credential. In any case, here is here's both my initial credential and the evaluation credential. And then the verifier verifies the credential which is about the cryptography and about the the um the things you don't need business rules to evaluate. Um and then second is is
Joe Andrieu: business rules which includes is this biometric evaluator a check provider? Is that an acceptable pro provider? Is it an an acceptable biometric? Right? Because the credentials signed, the credentials untampered with, but maybe it's some, you know, weird biometric that you don't know about or you don't respect or you don't allow. Right? So this is this is about policy um and the actual verification of um or not the validation of who provided the uh credentials um…
Joe Andrieu: which includes the original one right because this could be a DMV driver's license. Well I said it was a teaching certificate my example. So is that a teaching certificate from a recognized accredited authority? Right? That's part of validation.
Joe Andrieu: Um, and a semi-new satisfy all that with this. Now, now you can get the service. Okay, we'll put you in our our substitute teacher database. So, cool.
Scott Jones: cut it.
Joe Andrieu: Um, if you want to kick that around or you have any questions, we can talk a little bit more, but just getting your feedback on this has helped quite a bit.
Scott Jones: Can't think of anything right now.
Scott Jones: I'm I'm still wrapping my head around in person versus digital.
Scott Jones: It's fascinating. I've never I've never dealt with I've I've dealt with that like getting a license.
Joe Andrieu: Yeah. So,…
Scott Jones: That's about it. I'm I'm trying to wrap my head around this world.
Joe Andrieu: it also for um uh it's not a biometric template,…
Joe Andrieu: but is a biometric image um for proof of eligibility to work in the United States.
Scott Jones: Yep. Yep.
Joe Andrieu: So, if you've worked legally in the United States, um you've you participated in the filling out of this form and there must be a representative of the firm uh and there must be the employer employee sorry in the same room and then the representative walks through the protocol as defined on the form which is you can either have one thing from column A or one thing from B and one thing from C and I believe B is a photograph graphic um uh credential from a known authority like your driver's license,…
Joe Andrieu: but your driver's license just ties your legal name to a photo. It doesn't prove that you're eligible to work in the United States. So, so the second thing is a social security card or birth certificate or something else that does establish. Column A does both at the same time.
Scott Jones: Yep. Mhm.
Scott Jones: Yeah. Yep.
Joe Andrieu: So, that's passport for example. Um and that route,…
Joe Andrieu: you know, they're just they have to check the image. That's the whole point.
Joe Andrieu: like you must have something with an image and then the human person is going to evaluate that image against the employee and convince themselves that it's right.
Scott Jones: Yep. Yep.
Federal Wrap Sheet Process
Joe Andrieu: Um, so that's part of the deep anchor here where we're like we know there are instances um or in the US to get your um I don't know if you've ever uh gone through the trouble to get your federal wrap sheet.
Scott Jones: What is that?
Scott Jones: Federal wrap sheet. That sounds like I was thinking like the crimes you've committed. I'm not sure.
Joe Andrieu: Uhhuh. Yes.
Joe Andrieu: Yes. That's exactly what I'm talking about.
Scott Jones: Oh, well,…
Joe Andrieu: So, in order in order to get an official copy of the the crimes on record in the federal database,…
Scott Jones: I've never done that.
Joe Andrieu: you have to submit a biometric sample. You have to go get fingerprints and they have to be correct. Um, and they make it very scary.
Joe Andrieu: And if you're in any kind of hurry, you don't do it yourself. Like you could download this form and you could fingerprint yourself, but they make it clear if you mess up then you uh they're just they're just going to cancel it and you have to reapply and it'll cost you money again and you know it'll it takes six to eight weeks for us to process blah blah blah and…
Joe Andrieu: that you'll have to redo all of that. Um so if you're doing it for anything that needs to be timely, you're going to go to a service bureau. Um, and…
Scott Jones: Yeah. All right.
Joe Andrieu: you know, they'll they'll do it correctly. They'll they'll use the correct form and they'll use the correct technique and they will make sure that on their judgment they got good ink for all of your fingers, right? All the all that jazz. Um, so that was the other pattern, right, that we've seen in these high assurance situations.
Joe Andrieu: Um, so yep.
Scott Jones: Well, now I've got this in my mind.
Scott Jones: There's a use case if you need your federal wrap sheet.
Joe Andrieu: Yeah, it's an interesting.
Scott Jones: I went to like mafia personas thinking through that. That's fascinating.
Joe Andrieu: Yep. Well, you know, the the interesting thing well, one aspect of that that I it'll be interesting to see where it moves beyond that. It's actually that it's OBIM,…
Joe Andrieu: the Office of Biometric Identity Management. They're the guys in the US government who have all these fingerprints and…
Scott Jones: Mhm. Yep.
Joe Andrieu: all your passport photos. Um like it's their job to manage that data. Um the fingerprints are because criminals get fingerprinted. So when you're we've been and we've been doing that I don't know 100 years maybe you know 1926 maybe I would believe we started fingerprinting around that time.
Scott Jones: Yep. Oh,…
Joe Andrieu: Um so we just have we have that data. We don't have other forms of biometrics right. Um so I don't know when the cops are going to start moving to iris scans or what have you.
Scott Jones: yeah. That's freaky. Look forward to that one.
Joe Andrieu: Yeah, interesting world we're living in.
Joe Andrieu: I mean, I' I'd rather have the Irish scan than flock cameras. Scott Jones:
Scott Jones: Indeed. Yes. Yeah, I saw a video.
Joe Andrieu: I mean, I get it if I'm legitimately arrested. And I also get that the police can be abusive and and it can be used in inappropriately by the state, blah blah blah. But at least there's some due process in that whereas the flock stuff just man so annoying. Um it's Scott Jones:
Scott Jones: I saw a video. I don't know. I didn't like trace the attribution on it and figure out exactly what I was seeing. But it was the tagline was essentially Hey, if you're if you're a criminal, don't use a car because it was showing how this they somehow knew this person was going to commit a crime.
Scott Jones: So, they were following it with a drone and it looked Yeah. Um, and it was like the level of detail and the ease with which they followed this car. It's like, wow. Yeah, I get it. Uh, criminals don't use cars. Yeah.
Joe Andrieu: Yep. Yep.
Joe Andrieu: Well, I don't live in poor neighborhoods. I've our um we have a a housekeeper who comes every other week and helps us out for a couple hours. Um which if I were a kid I would have thought was decanent like what you made like you know and I guess I am doing a little bit better in my life than I was as a kid but um you know we become friends because we chat while she's you know vacuuming or whatever.
Joe Andrieu: Um, and like yeah, in her neighborhood they have drones overhead all the time.
Scott Jones: Holy s***. In San Diego area.
Joe Andrieu: It's it's uh Gu Ventura. Um, but yeah, so she lives over in the mobile park area. Like I don't know if she's actually in a mobile home, but like she's in a known like poor area. Um, and she is under excessive scrutiny in my opinion relative to the value to society to have those drones flying over there. But it's so easy to pop a drone up. You know, it's not like you're putting a helicopter out.
Joe Andrieu: The cost factor is is much much less. So, that's right.
Scott Jones: Yeah, that's nuts.
Scott Jones: And then you hook that up to AI and then it starts predicting and saying, "Oh, that person walking from that trailer to that trailer is probably planning something." Which
Joe Andrieu: Well, and part of the weirdness, I forgot who told me this.
Joe Andrieu: um someone who is involved I want I want to say it was one of the Ventura um flock deployments um but now that I can't remember who told me this um uh oh it was Utah it was a Utah um uh…
Joe Andrieu: because I was chatting with one of the guys on the privacy commission and they found that one of their flock cameras had been accessed like hundreds of times s by this um police department in Texas.
Scott Jones: Yep. Yes.
Joe Andrieu: And so it's it's a it's this nationwide access that in my opinion straight up violates due process. Um like I don't I don't know…
Joe Andrieu: how it would pass constitutional muster at all.
Scott Jones: Well, did you see that flock cameras um I haven't validated this myself either,…
Scott Jones: but saw videos,…
Scott Jones: multiple videos about it, where if you um if you had a system to detect infrared light when people walk by them, they're actually capturing their faces. They're not just looking at cars and…
Joe Andrieu: Oh, sure.
Joe Andrieu: Absolutely. Yep.
Scott Jones: it's capturing like your walking style, your gate, all this stuff to make p profiles of the humans, not just the cars.
Joe Andrieu: Have you have you heard of the use of Wi-Fi to to um detect people in the building?
Scott Jones: Uh, yes. I heard that a very long time ago and it seemed ridiculous and now now Yes.
Joe Andrieu: Now it's a product being sold as a security feature.
Scott Jones: Yep. Yep. Yeah. Mhm. Yeah.
Joe Andrieu: So it's like um I forget those services that people would have you know but it's a motion detection or things on the door and it calls you know when there might be a burglar and a security guy will come by and see what's going on right so I have seen now multiple ads for that service running on your router um and penetrating the walls to do surveillance of humans and the other use case in this same ad well it might be a different ad campaign but same company, different ad series that's about catching your teenager sneaking out at night.
Joe Andrieu: It's uh it's a grim world we're living in.
Scott Jones: So then to uh…
Scott Jones: then the teenagers will be like, "Well, cool. My protocol is I turn off our internet before I break out." Yeah.
Joe Andrieu: That's right. I don't know, Mom. Our internet keeps breaking down. Yeah.
Scott Jones: I don't get it. And it's always when I'm going to a party. Wait, did I say that out loud?
Joe Andrieu: I mean, you know, just, you know, I know it's it it sounds flippant,…
Joe Andrieu: but raise kids that you can trust. You know, provide some boundaries, punish them if they act badly, teach them some manners and some etiquette. I feel like an old man.
Scott Jones: That was that was the big So I had a session at GDC uh about holder binding and…
Scott Jones: when and when when and when not is it appropriate and Brent Zundle was there as like the counterbalance saying it's never appropriate and so we had yeah very interesting conversations like David Kel was the moderator and…
Joe Andrieu: Oh, good.
Joe Andrieu: Yeah. I said,… Scott Jones:
Scott Jones: he was saying, "So, my kids in a convenience store has got a fake ID and you're saying that's okay." He's like, "Talk to your kids. We don't need a surveillance state. Talk to your kids." Why is he even thinking about buying alcohol?
Joe Andrieu: "Why is your kid alone in a convenience store?" I mean,…
Scott Jones: How are you What are you doing to your kid? Yeah, it's all of that.
Joe Andrieu: if either the kid is old enough to go to the store on his own or he's not. Like I mean you had to make a choice as to whether or…
Joe Andrieu: not you told them or allowed him to get out of the house on his own. Um and I feel bad for kids today. They are under so much surveillance. It's a very disturbing and distorting psychological context compared to I was a ly kid.
Joe Andrieu: I mean, I had so much unsupervised time.
Scott Jones: Yeah. Well,…
Scott Jones: it seems um it's almost like they're being conditioned to accept that world that's taking shape. Yep. Yeah,…
Joe Andrieu: Yep. Well, part of it's just advertising, right? They're they're conditioned by they, oh, these are the products that are advertised to me. They must be okay. All right, we got our works. cut out for us, Scott. All right.
Scott Jones: I'm trying.
Joe Andrieu: Well, let's go ahead and wrap the meeting. I'm happy to get a half hour back. Um, and I'll check in with Denin. Maybe something come up with him. Uh, I think next week is Turkey Day, right? So,…
Scott Jones: All right.
Joe Andrieu: um, and then the third I'm out, but um, I'll let Dan make a call. He has been working on the questionnaires for horizontal review. Um, so that is likely what we'd be talking about on the third.
Joe Andrieu: Um, but I'm going to be at a conference. Um, so I won't make it. Um, but look look for the status of the meeting in the calendar.
Scott Jones: Sounds great.
Scott Jones: Thank you very much.
Joe Andrieu: All right.
Scott Jones: Have a great rest of your morning. Bye.
Joe Andrieu: Cool. Yeah, you too. Cheers. Meeting ended after 00:30:52 👋 This editable transcript was computer generated and might contain errors. People can also change the text after it was created.