Participants
- Barry Pollard, Nic Jansma, Yoav Weiss, Patrick Meenan, Andy Luhrs, Joone Hur, Noam Helfman, Guohui Deng, Mike Henniger, Monica Chintala, Sean Feng, Benjamin De Kosnik, Luis Flores, Philip Tellis
Admin
- Next call - Apr 24th?
- We’ve had some volunteers for helping issue triage, will look for some time over the next few
Minutes
Reporting API status - Yoav
- Yoav: Colleague tried to add support to Rails for Reporting Endpoint header
- … Answer they got was that this was still experimental technology, so Rails would not be interested in adding support
- … Tried to chime in to relevant PR and didn’t get a response
- … Unsure why they are concerned it’s “experimental”
- … Implemented in Chromium and Webkit
- Sean: Firefox has it implemented but behind a flag
- Yoav: … Two potential reasons
- … MDN marked as experimental due to browser compat
- … That part is fixed and no longer marked as experimental
- … Other potential reason to think this is the spec is in a Working Draft status
- … Published spec is up to date, but in WD status
- … Nothing preventing us from pushing this to CR other than unsure if anyone did work to make it happen
- … I suggest that we do, Reporting API is currently stable
- … No active workstream to change it
- … Opinion is we should make it a Living Standard
- … Path to that is pushing it through CR initially
- … Thoughts from others on the call?
- … As far as I know, we need to kick off wide review
- … Send a Call for Consensus (CfC) on the list
- … Potentially an AC vote? Not sure of the details
- Nic: Firefox implementation details?
- Sean: Reporting API implemented but a few parts that are not yet
- Yoav: For CSP for example, do you only support report-url and not report-to?
- Sean: I think it’s entirely disabled at the moment
- … We still support traditional way that doesn’t use Reporting API
- … But I don’t see why we shouldn’t move it forward
- Barry: My experience is many people look at MDN, less at spec ownership
- … Maybe a few more places to update
- … Moving spec is separate issue in my mind probably
- Yoav: Looking at MDN page now, seems
- … BCD updated but didn’t affect this portion immediately
- Barry: Should have a checkmark for Safari, but still LA until Firefox supports it
- … If you take Reporting API link, it still shows Experimental
- Yoav: So should fix BCD data
- Barry: I’ll submit a PR for a fix
- Yoav: Make sure MDN is reflecting reality
- Nic: Sounds like we have positivity from Mozilla, Chrome. No Apple reps on call.
- Yoav: Start with CfC for CR, then move to Living Standard
- Nic: Ian had been driving a lot of the spec work for Reporting API on Chromium, but he’s not as focused. Might need someone to pick up Spec work
- Andy: I might be able to, unsure